Resident takes dresser from street after neighbor throws it away, only to be confronted by other neighbor who claims the dresser is hers: ‘[I] wanted it first’

One person's garbage can be another person's treasure, and in the case of these neighbors, it was two people's treasure, which led to quite an awkward dispute.

Let's break it down. Neighbor number one is moving out, and they have a lot of furniture they don't need anymore. So, they decided to do a yard sale for some items and simply leave out anything else that could help someone else in the neighborhood. Hence, one person's garbage. Now, neighbor number two saw the furniture out on the street, and one dresser caught their eye. They knew their younger sister could really do with a new dresser, so they decided to take it. Another person's treasure, right? However, there was a third neighbor, a woman who also thought the dresser was treasure, and she claimed that neighbor number two should give it to her, even though they got to it first.

So, who should get the treasure?